The names "Old Bald Peg," "Old Peg" and "Cream Cheeks" appear for the first time in the fifth edition of Volume 1 of the General Stud Book, published in 1891, some two hundred years after their deaths. "LEEDES ARABIAN MARE (sister to Leedes, sometimes called Cream Cheeks), Bred by Mr Leedes" [GSB 1:12]. Leedes Arabian Mare was without her own entry in the General Stud Book until 1891, when she was credited with all the progeny previously credited to a sister to Leedes. It is possible that there was more than one sister to Leedes.

Tifter was attributed to Mr Leedes' Cream Cheeks in 1891, although there is some evidence that he was from Sir John Parsons' Cream Cheeks, the 2nd dam of Cinnamon (ch c 1722). "Tifter, Sir John Parson's, (by the Thoulouse Barb, out of Cream Cheeks, the grandam of Cinnamon)" [Pick 1:xxviii].

There is also some evidence that Tifter's dam was called young Cream Cheeks. "Tifter was Son of the Thoulouse Barb, out of young Cream Cheeks which was full sister in Blood to Leeds's" [Pond 1754:159].

Supporting evidence for the 1891 version is supplied by an advertisement in the March 6, 1753 issue of the Pennsylvania Gazette, in which a pedigree is given for the imported horse, Young Tifter, a grandson of Tifter. "Tifter of Warwick was got by the famous Thoulouse Barb, and bred out of Cream Cheeks, full sister to Leedes and grandam of Old Childers" [E2:53]. However, this may just be an indication of how early Tifter's pedigree became confused.

Yet another version of Tifter's pedigree can be found in Lord Rockingham's collection which notes that Mr Crofts said that the dam of Tifter was got by Counsellor - Brimmer - Dicky Pearson - Burton Barb Mare.

Tifter was bred by Sir John Parsons and it is reasonable to question whether his dam was Mr Leedes' Cream Cheeks rather than Sir John's own Cream Cheeks. In order to satisfy the "sister in blood" description of Young Cream Cheeks, it is possible that Tifter's pedigree connects at some point to Family 6, although his pedigree should probably look something like this:

Hautboy Mare (f 1695c Hautboy)
     Parson's Cream Cheeks (f 1700c Spanker)
          Tifter (c 1710c Thoulouse Barb)
          The Ryegate Mare (f 1709c Thoulouse Barb)
                Cinnamon (ch c 1722 Wyndham)